Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Photography

I've just discovered that one of my photographs is on the Guardian website for its 17 chosen shots following its June photography competition.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/travel/gallery/2008/jul/02/photocompetition.jun08?picture=335366599

That's nice!

Saturday, July 5, 2008

Mural creation at CCH

Today was the beginning of the creation of the CCH mural. Upon arrival at the orphanage the director told me about the building works that had taken place since I was last at the orphanage last week.

Previously the classrooms which were on the first floor of a building that is to the side of the dormitories had windows but they did not have any glass –they just had the usual iron bars every Cambodian house has (whether you have glass or not). Now, glass windows have been added which is great - Hopefully it will make the rooms better for teaching (quieter and less of the ever present dust).

About a month ago I saw that the building housing the classrooms actually also has a second floor as well (the stairs are somewhat hidden around the very back of the building) and that although rooms existed there was no building work in process. However, today the director told me that the rooms would be finished by the end of next week for children to sleep in – This includes a ceiling (there is a roof but no ceiling at present) and glass in the windows.

The director also told me he would like to paint the outside of the orphanage – the windows (and possibly some of the masonry – I’m not sure!) So the mural project has been expanded to painting not just a mural but all of the rooms and the outside of the building as well.... The children are going to help though with the painting of the outside (phew!).

I’ve designed the mural and today we drew the outline so that it can be painted next week.
My rough mural design for a wall that is about 10ft tall and 20ft wide....

It looks good at the moment although it is just an outline. Health and safety remains a non-existent factor in Cambodia – I moved the ladder to result in one of the ceiling beams falling down on me – Luckily quite light and metal framed! No injury.
In action!

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

The Khmer Rouge Tribunal (ECCC)

Being a (non-practising(!)) lawyer in Cambodia I guess it is about time that I devoted some time to talking about the ECCC – That is the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (commonly referred to as the Khmer Rouge Tribunal).
The ECCC just on the outskirts of Phnom Penh

An extremely condensed low down on the Khmer Rouge period...


The time in which the Khmer Rouge ruled Cambodia is probably one of the most horrific times in modern history. Between 1975 and 1979 the KR regime imposed brutal methods in an attempt to create a “pure Khmer” society based on agricultural production. In order to reach its aims they employed extreme means - torture, arbitrary executions, imprisonment with no trial, forced labour, persecution (of the religious and the educated or indeed anyone who opposed them). No proper health care was in place, food was rationed to the extent that people often starved to death. The Khmer Rouge forced people out of the cities and into the country. Adults and children were forced to work in the fields. Phnom Penh was practically deserted after a mass evacuation in 1975. The KR sought to erase any traditional and foreign cultural influences and sought to seek to destroy the Cambodian culture by “re-educating” people.

The KR’s mass killings resulted in huge mass graves (est, 200,000 graves) across the country. At least 189 torture/detention centres existed. The brutal regime and the execution of so many people make it impossible to estimate the scale of the killings but it is estimated that 20% of the population (1.7 million people) were killed. Some estimate the figures as high as 33%. This high figure is shocking to the core but not surprising when you consider what actions would make the Khmer Rouge kill a Cambodian – For instance, something as simple as eating an insect you have taken from the ground and eating it because you are starving to death or going to the toilet without permission from a KR official could have resulted in your torture or execution.

I cannot begin to detail the atrocities committed by the KR here or give the detail of the crimes committed giving the coverage those who suffered deserve. A good starting point for the interested (and short on time) is the famous movie “The Killing Fields”. There are numerous first hand books covering the situations faced by individuals who miraculously survived. I would recommend “Survival in the Killing Fields” (Haing Ngor) or either of the books by Loung Ung.

In the meantime instant condensed information can be found at http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7002629.stm

The punishment of the Khmer Rouge


It was the Vietnamese invasion into Cambodia which eventually toppled the Khmer Rouge. Since the fall of the KR (and since the UN and the governments of the world stopped recognising the KR as the official government of Cambodia in favour of the communist Vietnamese) numerous bodies have been calling for the perpetrators to be brought to justice. It is only since 1990 that serious thought has been given to the matter. However, in 1979 Cambodia did itself try and bring “justice” by holding its own tribunal (People’s Revolutionary Tribunal) - However, the verdict of this tribunal is not considered to be just by the International Community as the trial only lasted 5 days and was given in absentia of those accused with no real hearing of the evidence.

The problems with establishing the ECCC are numerous - One problem is that so many people were perpetrators carrying out the orders of the KR. Former torturers drive moto taxis, work in the market, work in the fields and are in the present government (although they defected from the KR)...They are indistinguishable from the other Cambodians who were the victims.

Also decades have passed since the atrocities were committed. A further problem is that if the KR leaders who were convicted by the Cambodian tribunal joined the government, then government pardoned them – leaving a problem with a) the fact that they can claim they have already been convicted (double jeopardy rule) combined with the fact that b) they have been pardoned!


Here is a very quick legal overview of the aspects to be considered by the ECCC.


  • The tribunal will only hear accounts of crimes committed between 1975 and 1979. The accused may therefore use the defence that his/her acts were committed outside of this time frame.

  • The ECCC will try the crimes of Senior leaders alone (although many of the most infamous leaders have died - Pol Pot being an obvious example). The court will have the responsibility to decide exactly who was a 'senior leader' and who was 'most responsible' for the crimes committed by the Khmer Rouge.

  • Defendants of the ECCC may be held liable for either direct or superior responsibility. If the defendant planned the act/ordered it etc then he/she may be liable. This is important because many of the Senior leaders did not actually kill/torture people themselves but ordered other people to do it (who would have been almost certainly killed had they not done as asked)

  • Only certain crimes may be judged by the Court – It will focus on the most serious offences under international and Cambodian law (more on this below)

  • The law must be applied as it was in 1975-1979. Modern interpretations should not be given. So, the crimes (such as genocide and crimes against humanity) and the principles (such as direct or superior responsibility) must be interpreted as the law stood at this time.


The crimes to be tried



The ECCC will hear evidence on the charges of any of the following crimes:



Genocide

The elements of genocide are:

(a) an individual commits a prohibited act; The acts are: killing/causing serious harm/inflicting conditions to bring about the groups destruction/measures to prevent birth/forcibly transferring children.

(b) with an intent to destroy; The accused must be shown to have committed one of the acts above against at least one of the protected groups below with an intention to destroy that group in whole or part.

(c) in whole or part a national, ethical, racial or religious group; the victims must be a member of one of these groups.

(d) Some argue that the crime also has a 4th element – That the prohibited act was “part of a manifest pattern of similar conduct or that it was the type of conduct that could bring about the destruction of the group in whole or in part”. This is not however decided under International Law and may be a new area of law the Tribunal rules upon.


Crimes against humanity


In general crimes against humanity include grave abuses committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against civilians on racial, political, religious, national or ethnic grounds.

(a) A prohibited act must be committed –murder/extermination/enslavement/deportataion/ imprisonment/torture/rape/persecution/or “other inhumane acts”;

(b) The act must be “widespread or systematic”. Some argue that in the 1970s the acts must be “widespread and systematic”. It is more widely thought however, that if the attacks are part of an organised policy or series of attacks then generally this is enough for this element of the crime;

(c) the attacks must be against civilians in the protected groupings: racial, political, religious, national or ethnic. Other tribunals (in Yugoslavia and Rwanda) have not required discriminatory intent towards the group. Whether the ECCC also takes this approach remains to be seen;

(d) the mental element – “knowing that the attacks are widespread and systematic”. The individuals needed to know that what they were doing was part of a broader attack.



“War crimes” – Beaches of the Geneva Convention

The 4 1949 Geneva Conventions – These protect certain groups such as civilians, prisoners and soldiers in times of war (by the 1970s it was established that this meant international armed conflict). This will limit the prosecution as the KR atrocities were domestic abuses. However, article 3 of the Conventions can apply outside international armed conflict:

a) Article 3 protects the most fundamental of rights such as murder, torture and the right to a fair trial. The context of these crimes, to secure a conviction, however must be in the “nexus of an armed conflict”. It is not clear whether the ECCC judges will find that there was a sustained conflict in Cambodia between 1975 and 1979 but it is more likely to find that there was a conflict between 1977 and 1978 when the border conflict with Vietnam escalated.

b) The harm must have been inflicted willingly.

The Convention on Cultural Property


There is a possibility of the charge of destruction of cultural property. However, this treaty only applies to sovereign states not individuals – it is not a crime but a measure to allow states to get finaincial compensation from other states - Therefore the ECCC may be reluctant to stretch the law so that it applies to individuals as a crime. However, such crime may exist as a customary law.


Crimes against Internationally Protected Persons


This poses the same problem as above – It is a state based remedy not a crime. There is a separate treaty which allows for this to be a crime but Cambodia is not a party to this treaty and it is not mentioned in the ECCC law. Again, customary law may be used by the judges to overcome this hurdle



Domestic crimes (such as homicide, torture, religious persecution)



The 1956 Cambodia Penal Code may also be used to bring charges against the accused (the crimes being murder, torture and religious persecution). However, Cambodian jurisprudence is not well developed and so what makes up the elements of these crimes in the 1970s is not at all clear. The ECCC judges will therefore have considerable discretion. This is almost a safety net for the tribunal. Being convicted of hundreds of murders does not have the same stigma as a conviction for genocide but would still lead to a considerable prison sentence.



Finally - The purpose of the law lecture!

This week Ieng Sary (former Khmer Rouge foreign minister) has been in front of the ECCC and hitting the Cambodian (and international headlines). The ECCC is hearing matters prior to his trial kicking off properly –Preliminary matters. On Monday Sary asked for the Tribunal to rise early because he felt dizzy and tired. [Ummm – I’d like to say that must have been just like how the millions of people he put to work in the fields on no food/water in the baking head for 4 years felt before they were killed or died of disease/malnutrition but that would be politically incorrect.]

At present the ECCC is hearing his bail application. His lawyers claim he should be released due to poor health and that he should be placed under house arrest instead. The concern is that he will not otherwise be fit to stand trial in approximately a year’s time (he is 82 years old). The ECCC is also expected to hear arguments as to whether he should be facing trial at all.

It is expected that his lawyers will argue whether the pardon he was granted (see above) by former king Norodom Sihanouk makes it impossible for the ECCC to charge him. The interesting thing is that he is now charged with war crimes and crimes against humanity. He has previously been convicted by the People’s Revolutionary Tribunal for Genocide. The pardon that followed was therefore for the Genocide conviction – Genocide is not the same crime as those present charges of crimes and crimes against humanity so how double jeopardy or the pardon can apply seems to be a bit of a non-argument... It’s simply not the same crime.

Sary's wife Ieng Thirith, Khieu Samphan (former head of state), Nuon Chea (chief ideologist) and Kaing Guek Eav (former Toul Sleng torture centre director and also known as Duch) are the other KR leaders currently in detention awaiting trial. Duch is expected to have his trial begin in September.

I promise other posts on the subject will be shorter... I was having law withdrawal symptoms!

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

The application of the rule of law in Cambodia...

Yesterday evening, returning home at about 10pm I saw the aftermath of a crash at the end of our street. There was an ambulance (rare) and lots of Khmers standing around the scene. There was no car and so it looked like a sole drunken motorbike wobble/accident. I have read elsewhere that the rumour is that the incident was the result of a drunken Australian who drove around the Independence Monument roundabout and in his drunkeness veered into a motorbike resulting in killing two people and injuring one other. Apparently, no action will be taken as the individual is on secondment to a Governemental department or similar.... Exceptionally sad. So typical here. This is in addition to the armed robberies (day and night) going on at the moment.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Monday...

School in the morning and working towards various projects in the afternoon results in nothing really interesting to report. However, the election campagin is hotting up with the CPP party parading down the street this afternoon. The hotel next door to the apartment I think is in favour of the 3rd party - Sam Rainsy. They have not put up any banners/signs though....


Party political truck and moto




The eldery lady was back this afternoon so, after deciding that there was no point keeping the unopened rice and noodles that were in the kitchen, given eating out is so easy (and less hot!) I took them out to her. I wish I could speak more Khmer to talk to her properly.






I am working on the mural for CCH's classroom and now just need to source the paint - Given I need all sorts of colours this may be difficult!



Moto drivers and the guard waiting





These power cables are the main electricity cables - Scary!

Sunday, June 29, 2008

Giving and taking...

There is unsurprisingly a number of people begging in Phnom Penh. This can be quite challenging for some but I have found the beggars here to be far less persistent and "in your face" than in other countries I have visited. Even the begging in the tourist areas is often done with an element of good spirit and the children selling the books on the riverside often appear to be more interested (as they should be, being children(!)) in playing and winding each other up rather than the hard sell.

Whether to give is a personal choice but (not being the un-opinionated type) it is in my view a foolish thing to do when children are involved. Many of the children begging in Phnom Penh are put there by their parents who know that their child can earn more begging than they could in a job. The children do not therefore go to school, they cannot get a job and the begging cycle remains with them in adulthood. Many of the beggar children run around the Riverfront (the main tourist drag - I suppose the equivalent in London might be Piccadilly Circus...) completely naked. I think this may be part of the begging act to get more money rather than complete poverty but is obviously totally inhumane to the children.

One of the things that disgusts me here is the fact that some adults run what I call "glue stands". These are stands where children, who cannot afford to buy a whole tube of glue to sniff, go to buy a little bit of glue in a plastic bag to inhale. I am horrified that people would run such an outfit - aimed at vulnerable children. This is also where your money may go on giving money to the street children. Far better to buy them a meal or a drink of clean water. That said, on offering this you can work out the genuine needy and hungry from the more fake.... Needless to say the fakers will turn it down and press for more money.

I do however give some money to an ancient old lady who begs on our street. She is a "regular" beggar and the moto taxi drivers are always very happy with me when I give her some cash even if it is only about 500 Riel (about 6p/$0.12). I have only ever given to one other old lady who accosted me as soon as I got off a moto taxi away from home - She was not impressed with the 500 Riel I gave her (which I know to be fair as the regular is always thanking me far too much for this amount). From now on I will certainly 0nly give to the lady on my street.

Here she is with some monks...


Another very frustrating thing is the moto drivers who try and rip you off for journeys. I never negotiate the fare - Just get off the bike at the end of the journey and pay them the amount that you know is about right (or often a bit more). This week however I have had a number of drivers complain at the amount offered. They obviously have inflated ideas when a foreigner gets on the bike. I have even had discussions in Khmer with the second, third and fouth rip off merchants telling him I am not a tourist, that I work in Stung Meancheay and how much it costs to get there (much further than the journey he just made with me) and why the price was therefore fair....ummm good Khmer practice but I just prefer a quiet moto ride and a non angry driver. Its quite funny when they are surprised I speak some Khmer - Luckily they do not speak back too much otherwise they would immediately find out that my Khmer is limited!!

Saturday, June 28, 2008

School and a meeting at CCH

Friday is a good day at school as I get to make lots of mess and see the look on the children's faces when I tell them about one artist or another. This week it was Picasso and the Three Musicians painting. The result - Not as good as the Van Gogh's but at least they tried!



The results of a morning of Picasso and work in progress.



In the afternoon Brian and I went to CCH to speak to the director. We established with him that I could run a photography course with 5 of the students with the cameras donated and that I could paint one of the classrooms for the younger children... ideally with an educational mural! I have designed the mural and now just need to get buying the paint/brushes/rollers etc. Hopefully I will start it next week.


Lily Heng and Panha - reading the alphabet bird book(!)




The girl who was introduced to me as Goy in March ...but now appears to be called something beginning with S (Sinda perhaps?)
...Its best when he doesn't know I am there otherwise I get all sorts of very odd poses!



Although some of them can be quite arty I suppose!